Breaking up (with your credit card company) is hard to do

Is it possible to cut off my credit card without hurting myself? Photo: Ava Dugdale

I frequently undertake arbitrary challenges to keep life entertaining. I once challenged myself to go without a haircut for a year. In light of one reader’s comments on a column I wrote for CBC, I recently challenged myself to go 60 days without my credit card.

Super. Easy. One minor hiccup. Really.

Now that I have emergency savings, I don’t need to use my card. I planned to cancel it.

But…hold up. Bad idea, said my more money-conscious friends. It will result in a hit to your credit score, they said.

I am very protective of my credit score. For me, it’s like a Good Girl Score.

I needed to find out if this was fact, so I spoke with Brian Betz from Money Mentors – a non-profit organization that helps people learn about money management. He said the most important factor in determining credit is whether or not you pay your bills on time. Check.

He said the second most important factor is credit utilization: how much credit you have versus how much you’re using. He said that if I cancel my card – and I don’t have anything else to vouch for my credit-handling abilities, such as a bank loan or line of credit – it could hurt me if I ever need to apply for credit again. “Sometimes, having no credit is just as bad as having bad credit,” Betz says. “We live, unfortunately, in a credit-oriented society.”


You know that fantasy you have about going back in time to that one super abusive relationship you had, and being the one to end it, the one to decide when it was over. I had that fantasy. I was going to call up my credit card company and politely, and smugly, tell the nice person who answered the phone to get bent.

Frankly, my naivety around this subject shows just how little I knew when I signed up for this card when I was in university, more than 10 years ago. Instead of cancelling my card, Betz offered this advice. Use your credit card, not like money, but like a different means to pay your way.

“It’s not a credit card,” he says. “It’s a payment card.”

“It’s a convenience tool.”

For me, this idea has been a slippery slope. I’ve started out this way – using my credit card to pay for things and then paying off the balance immediately – many times. Somehow, I always slid. I started justifying purchases for things I didn’t need (clothing, mostly) with money I didn’t have (the credit card company’s, mostly).

The end of my 60-day challenge serendipitously coincided with the day I paid off the final $100 left on my credit card statement. It felt good. Given this fact, right now is the best time for me to start a new relationship with my credit card. One that’s not abusive, but grown up and mature.


PS Need a serious wake up call regarding your borrowing? Watch either Maxed Out (it’s on Netflix or at the CPL) or Debt Trap (available at the CPL). Some of the political information is outdated, but the personal stories are heartbreakingly timeless.

Tagged , , , ,

3 thoughts on “Breaking up (with your credit card company) is hard to do

  1. Caitlin says:

    I don’t know if you travel much but if you do, you also want to have a credit card for rental car and hotel booking purposes. They often put a pending charge of a large amount (like, $500) for security then return when you check out and they deem no damage has been done to their property. If you don’t carry that much money in your checking account for whatever reason, you may run into issues while you are traveling.

  2. Sha Sha says:

    Funny, I was going to tell you about the credit score thing before you cut up your credit card as that happened to a co-worker of mine. She had to get a credit card so that she could get a mortgage. It didn’t matter that she had a high paying job that she has held for over 12 years and pays all of her bills on time and had a previous mortgage a few years ago with the same bank.. It was like she didn’t exist in the credit world so they wouldn’t give her a mortgage.

    • This story makes me furious. A woman who has a high-paying job for more than a decade, and has a track record of bill payment ISN’T a good risk for a mortgage? She needs a freaking credit card to prove it?!?!?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: